"Rational Guide to Spelling"
Camden Weekly Phenix, May 22, 1858

View transcription
"Rational Guide to Spelling"
We have received from Mr. J. B. Menny a mental production, with the above title. The author begins with the smallest words, and proceeds to those more complex. From the first class words he forms others, by prefixing one or more consonants; as from an are derived can, man, pan, &c. Also, by substituting one or more consonants for the initial letter, he from bag derives lag, nag, rag, &c. Among his rules of derivation is given the exceptions. To illustrate this, I copy entire Rule 4, thus:
Words ending y change into i when they take a syllable. Examples.—Happy, happiness; mercy, merciful. Exception.—Copy, copyer.
Many useful ideas are comprised in these 36 pages; and I unhesitatingly pronouce [sic] it a good book for our schools. It reduces into spelling an amount of system. While on this subject, it may interest some persons to state that well regulated printing offices have their own list of "doubtful orthography" posted up as a guide for their workmen. Such lists contain such words as moneys, [mon]ies; turnep, nip; authorise, ize, &c. Printers find generally but little difficulty in choosing their method of spelling such words. There is, occasionally, a snag to be met with. The word eighteen, for instance, when divided, (as occasionally it must be) is not uniform with its class or near neighbors, seven-teen and nine-teen. As the least of two evils, some printers double the t when dividing the word. If this is necessary on such occasions, (which I am not prepared to decide), what stronger reason than this do they need for retaining it altogether?
Advertisement