Feitz Witness Dies in 5-Floor City Hall Jump
Camden Evening Courier, September 5, 1934

View transcription
FEITZ WITNESS DIES IN 5-FLOOR CITY HALL JUMP
Should Have Been Kept in Cell, Stewart and Orlando Say
WOMAN TRIED IN VAIN TO TALK WITH WARD
Colsey Will Conduct Investigation in Attempt to Fix Blame
A complete investigation was ordered today by Mayor Roy R. Stewart into the suicide yesterday of Mrs. Emma Heisler, 38, who plunged five floors from a detective bureau window in city hall.
Mrs. Heisler was the key witness to the murder early Sunday of Detective William T. Feitz. It was in Mrs. Heisler's alleged disorderly house at 243 Sycamore street that Feitz was killed.
Mayor Stewart, ordering the investigation, freely admitted today that Mrs. Heisler should have been locked in a city hall jail cell instead of being permitted to roam about detective headquarters.
Colsey to Conduct Probe
Mayor Stewart delegated Police Chief Arthur Colsey to conduct the probe and determine whether there is evidence of police laxity in the suicide of Mrs. Heisler.
From two sources since the woman was taken into custody were the police warned against permitting her to walk unguarded in city hall. The warnings were ignored.
Only yesterday, a short time before the woman leaped to her death, a Courier-Post reporter made the comment in detective headquarters:
"You'd better watch that woman, or she's liable to jump from a window and sprain her ankle."
A similar warning that Mrs. Heisler should be locked in a cell was delivered by Prosecutor Samuel P. Orlando.
Less than an hour before she took her death leap, Mrs. Heisler had pleaded with Lieutenant Ward to let her talk to him.
"I've got something in my heart I must let out," she told Ward, interrupting him as he gave a last-minute telephone report of the murder probe to Mayor Stewart. The mayor was about to catch a 4.20 p. m. train to his Ocean City summer home.
Three times, Ward said, she tried to drag him from the telephone as he talked to Stewart, each time insisting she had something to tell him.
Ward Refused to Listen
Ward concluded the conversation with Stewart and then left the bureau instead of talking to her.
At 5.12 p. m. Mrs. Heisler rushed from the detectives' room into Ward's private office, raised the only window not guarded by a glass ventilator and leaped to her death.
Whatever she had in her heart was still there.
She never regained consciousness fully and died at 6.12 p. m. in Cooper Hospital.
With her, police believe, went their best chance of learning the identity of Feitz's slayers.
After Ward brusquely rebuffed the woman as she attempted to tell him something that he, by his own admission, believes might have been the identity of the killers, she went back into the desk room where all detectives sit when idle.
A Courier-Post reporter was outside the counter separating the detectives' office space from that area reserved for the public—barred from the inner sanctum by Ward's orders.
The reporter said the woman was disheveled in appearance, her blonde hair straggling about her face, her eyes showing that she was under a severe emotional strain.
Detectives Laugh
"You'd better watch that woman," he told Detective Robert Ashenfelder. "She's liable to jump from a window and sprain her ankle."
The detectives laughed.
A few minutes later she sat at a desk near the entrance to Ward's
(Continued on Page Two)
(Continued from Page One)
private office, in the corner of the bureau.
"She was about to break. I think she was ready to tell us who killed Feitz," Detective Sergeant Gus Koerner said afterward.
After Ward refused to let her unburden herself—possibly of information the entire department has been seeking night and day since Feitz's death—she appeared highly agitated.
The woman leaped from her desk and rushed into Ward's private office.
Body Broken Badly
She raised the only window not guarded by a ventilator and leaped. She landed on the iron windshield bar of a roadster, and the force of her fall almost cut her body in half. She bounced into the seat of the car owned by Andrew Stewart, 143 West Cottage avenue, Haddonfield.
Detectives Clifford Carr and Robert Ashenfelter were the only members of the force in the bureau. Carr was answering a telephone. Ashenfelter was questioning Camillo Cinelli, 848 South Third street, a former pugilist known as Billy Hart, about some matter not connected with the murder.
"We were standing almost at the door of Ward's office," Ashenfelter said. "Cinelli wanted a drink of water and I followed him to the water bottle, away from the door. We drank and started back.
"Cinelli was in front of me and I could not see the woman. All of a sudden we heard the sound of tinkling glass. Cinelli ran into Ward's office. I followed him. The woman was gone. We looked out the window and saw her in a roadster with the top down.
Takes Her to Hospital
"I went downstairs in the private elevator, loaded the woman into a car and went with her to Cooper Hospital. Carr went downstairs with me, but he had to return to the office."
Carr said he was answering a telephone when he heard the sound of glass, looked about for the woman and saw she was gone. Then he too rushed to Ward's window and looked out to see her in the car below.
The woman's skull was crushed. Her fall bent the metal bar of the windshield almost to the dash and shattered the glass—to give notice of her death to her previous captors upstairs.
At the hospital, Dr. Roscoe Kandle examined the woman and shook his head, then ordered her removed to a ward cot. She was in a semi-comatose state.
Carpani and Lieutenant Ward, who had rushed to the hospital for his delayed reception of her story, found her unable to tell what was in her heart.
Her brothers, Albert and William Slonski of 1300 South Broad street, Philadelphia, arrived before she died.
Father James Foley, pastor of Immaculate Conception Roman Catholic Church, administered extreme unction to the woman. He happened to be in the hospital, asked if she were a Catholic, and gave her the last rites of her faith for the living.
Neither Mayor Stewart nor Chief of Police Colsey would criticize any member of the detective force for the woman's leap, but Prosecutor Orlando was outspoken in his belief that police laxity, in spite of a warning from him, had caused her death and had removed the state's chief witness against Feitz's slayers, "if they are caught."
Orlando Warned Mayor
"At 2 p. m. today," Orlando said. "I told Mayor Stewart that woman ought to be locked in a cell and held on the charge of maintaining a disorderly house.
"It is a regrettable thing that she was permitted to commit suicide. It may prove costly in the prosecution of Feitz's slayers, if they are caught.
"I am not having much to do with the investigation. I am hoping the police will bring it to the point where I can prepare to prosecute."
"I will not criticize any member of the force for Mrs. Heisler's leap," Chief Colsey said. "We had agreed to allow Ward to have his way. He felt, and convinced us, that we could get more from her by treating her kindly.
'She Appeared Contented'
"As a matter of fact, she appeared contented. When Mayor Stewart and I questioned her earlier in the afternoon, she appeared in better condition than at any time since she was brought here.
"If she had wanted to leap from a window, she had had ample opportunities. She could have leaped while the mayor and I were questioning her, for that matter. We did not suspect she would attempt her life.
"She anwered questions better—more straightforwardly—for Mayor Stewart and me than at any time before.
"I believe she knew who killed Feitz. She said she didn't. I think she would have told us tonight who killed him. She was beginning to open up."
Ward, silent since Monday morning, said virtually the same thing, although he insisted he was "not talking anyway."
Ward Calls It Fear
"She was about ready to tell what she knew, the chief of detectives said. "It probably was fear that had kept her from it before. She feared she would be killed if she did tell. I think she knew who killed Feitz.
"She came to me three times while I was talking to Mayor Stewart on the phone and I had to put my hand over the phone to send her out," Ward confessed. "She kept saying she had something to tell me. I think she was ready to tell it all.
"I had to leave the office after talking to the mayor," Ward continued. "I didn't get to question her further. I wasn't here when she jumped. I'm not talking, anyway," Ward said.
It was Mayor Stewart who revealed that the woman told Ward "I've got something in my heart and I must let it out."
This, the mayor said, Ward told him on the telephone, interrupting the conversation to hear that much and then leaving the bureau before hearing what it was.
Disagrees With Colsey
Mayor Stewart's opinion of the woman's nervous condition was the reverse of Chief Colsey's, however. He said:
"The death of the Heisler woman is very unfortunate. But we believe it will not retard our investigation into Feitz's murder. We are hopeful that there are others who know just as much as Mrs. Heisler knew.
"I noticed this afternoon as Chief Colsey and I questioned her that she was in a very nervous condition. Several times she became flustered and appeared bewildered when attempting to answer questions.
"Her mind at times seemed to become a total blank."
'Ward's Idea'
Asked why the woman had not been booked and locked in a cell, Mayor Stewart said:
"This angle had been gone over very carefully several times and it was Ward's idea that Mrs. Heisler be given freedom of the bureau and treated with kindness, with the hope that she would reveal valuable information.
"I am sorry now I did not insist that she be placed in a cell.
"In the future, definite steps will be taken to prevent like happening."
Asked whether any disciplinary action would be taken against members of the detective bureau as punishment for laxity in watching the woman, the mayor said:
"No. There will be no such action. I acquiesced in Ward's desire to allow the woman freedom, trusting his judgment that this course might reduce the best results."
Voluntary Prisoner
Mrs. Heisler was allowed many privileges during her detention. She was held as a voluntary prisoner, Chief Colsey said, adding:
"But if she had wanted to leave, we would have booked her and put her in a cell."
He admitted the woman was held—though technically not held—in excess of the 48 hours police are permitted to hold a prisoner without filing charges.
"You can hold them as long as necessary in a murder case," Colsey said.
Rests in Comfort
For two days the Courier-Post Newspapers had been printing pointed stories to the effect that Mrs. Heisler was allowed free run of detective headquarters, being treated as a guest while all others linked in any way with the murder were locked up in cells.
She was not even sent to a cell to sleep. Detectives converted a bench in the line-up room, which opens onto their quarters, into a bed, using blankets, overcoats and other pieces of clothing and bedding, impounded as stolen, to make her comfortable.
Detectives Served Her
An unidentified friend was permitted to bring her $10 in cash. She was allowed to smoke at will, to eat when and what she desired, and to have coffee brought to her by detectives at any and all hours.
That the Heisler woman had operated disorderly houses for six or seven years in Camden was generally known, although police would not admit the knowledge.
She ran a place at Sixth and Spruce streets for a time; then operated another house at Third and Mechanic street, a third at Ninth and Pine streets, and still another at Second and Chestnut streets. Then she ran a house at 242 Sycamore street, moved away, and then opened a new place at 243 Sycamore street, where Feitz was killed. This place had been in operation about seven months.
Sergeant Koerner said the woman had shown every indication that she was on the point of "breaking."
'Bad Break' for Police
"She would walk up to me and other men as though she wanted to tell us something. Then she would turn and walk away. She was getting ready to tell everything, I believe. It is a bad break that she is dead.
"I think she knew who killed Feitz. The men had been there before. They had asked for her by name at the door, and she had admitted them. She is bound to have known them.
"She was ready to tell who they were, I believe, but every time she got to the point of telling, something would come up in her throat. I think it was fear."
Chief Colsey continued to drive all members of the force night and day on the investigation, determined, he said, to clean it up as soon as possible.
Advertisement