Camden Courier-Post, December 26, 1953View transcription
Sgt. Wilkie Is Still Held in Jail, His Bail of $50,000 Unchanged
Cut Considered After Retraction Of 'Confession'
Police Sgt. John V. Wilkie, Camden's notebook cop, remained in jail today in default of $50,000 bail despite his admission Thursday he "confessed" accidentally killing his son in an effort to have full burial rites of the Roman Catholic Church accorded the youth.
Wilkie's admission of the fabrication as a desperate self-sacrificing attempt for his son came Thursday afternoon after he learned the church had reiterated that his son, James, 17, could not be given requiem rites and be buried in consecrated ground.
Wilkie admitted that when he returned to his home, at 1144 Princess ave., at 2.18 a. m. Sunday, he found his son dead of a revolver shot instead of having been shot in a struggle with Wilkie for the latter's service revolver.
Services for Wilkie's son will be held Monday at 11 a. m. in the Robert J. Blake Funeral Home, 851 Haddon ave. Burial will be in New Camden Cemetery, Mt. Ephraim and Ferry aves., a nondenominational cemetery. There will be a public viewing at the funeral home Sunday night.
Wilkie, a member of Sacred Heart R.C. Church, Broadway and Ferry ave., will be permitted to attend the services under guard.
Asked about the continuing high bail, Prosecutor Mitchell Cohen said there has been "no request from Wilkie nor his attorney, Elmer Bertman, for reduction of bail."
Favorable to Lower Bail
Cohen, however, continued, "In light of the new circumstances, I certainly would entertain such a request." He continued:
"In view of the holiday weekend, I probably won't be in my office until Monday. Nor is the sheriff's office open during the weekend to receive the bail.
"It would be necessary to contact me with a request for bail reduction and also to make special arrangements with Sheriff Hainsworth to post the bail."
Late Thursday, Cohen told reporters he had no alternative but to present all of the facts in the case to the grand jury and 'let them decide.
Tells of Repudiation
"In the presence of Chief Mulligan and Capt. Dube of the county detectives staff; Capt. Murphy of the Camden City detective bureau;
(Continued on Page 4—Column 2)
Wilkie
(Continued From Page One)
Samuel P. Orlando as a friend of Wilkie's, and Fred Albert, court stenographer, Wilkie has made a statement which repudiates a 'confession' he made to me earlier this week.
"He states that he found his son, James, dead of a gunshot wound when he returned to his home early on the morning of Dec. 20.
"Wilkie states that he concocted his story that he and his son wrestled over possession of the gun, which was Wilkie's service revolver, and that the gun was discharged accidentally.
Father Denied Suicide
"Wilkie told us he had determined to do everything within his power, say anything and be willing to take any kind of punishment, in order to obtain a Catholic funeral for his son.
"He still insists that his son did not commit suicide, that he had just bought some new clothes and had said or done nothing to indicate he might take his life.
"I must say here that the facts available to us do not coincide with a theory of accidental death.
"After Wilkie had made his 'confession' to us, we had him illustrate several times with county detectives how he said he tussled with his son. We knew then the son could not have been accidentally shot in such a struggle.
State Police Tests
"All tests by state police laboratories and our medical reports clearly evidenced Wilkie was not telling the truth.
"The bullet entered one temple and emerged from the other on a straight line instead of at an angle. The course the bullet took made it clear the shot was fired with deliberation by a gun held in the decedent's hands or in some other hands.
"Since a complaint has been made and a court has instructed me to present this matter to the grand jury, I must do so. Therefore the charge of manslaughter will remain pending the grand jury's deliberation."
Wilkie, according to Sheriff Hainsworth, spent a "restful day" Christmas in a cell in E block on the sixth floor of City Hall.
The sheriff said Wilkie was in "good spirits and talked frequently with other prisoners."
Cut Considered After Retraction Of 'Confession'
Police Sgt. John V. Wilkie, Camden's notebook cop, remained in jail today in default of $50,000 bail despite his admission Thursday he "confessed" accidentally killing his son in an effort to have full burial rites of the Roman Catholic Church accorded the youth.
Wilkie's admission of the fabrication as a desperate self-sacrificing attempt for his son came Thursday afternoon after he learned the church had reiterated that his son, James, 17, could not be given requiem rites and be buried in consecrated ground.
Wilkie admitted that when he returned to his home, at 1144 Princess ave., at 2.18 a. m. Sunday, he found his son dead of a revolver shot instead of having been shot in a struggle with Wilkie for the latter's service revolver.
Services for Wilkie's son will be held Monday at 11 a. m. in the Robert J. Blake Funeral Home, 851 Haddon ave. Burial will be in New Camden Cemetery, Mt. Ephraim and Ferry aves., a nondenominational cemetery. There will be a public viewing at the funeral home Sunday night.
Wilkie, a member of Sacred Heart R.C. Church, Broadway and Ferry ave., will be permitted to attend the services under guard.
Asked about the continuing high bail, Prosecutor Mitchell Cohen said there has been "no request from Wilkie nor his attorney, Elmer Bertman, for reduction of bail."
Favorable to Lower Bail
Cohen, however, continued, "In light of the new circumstances, I certainly would entertain such a request." He continued:
"In view of the holiday weekend, I probably won't be in my office until Monday. Nor is the sheriff's office open during the weekend to receive the bail.
"It would be necessary to contact me with a request for bail reduction and also to make special arrangements with Sheriff Hainsworth to post the bail."
Late Thursday, Cohen told reporters he had no alternative but to present all of the facts in the case to the grand jury and 'let them decide.
Tells of Repudiation
"In the presence of Chief Mulligan and Capt. Dube of the county detectives staff; Capt. Murphy of the Camden City detective bureau; Samuel P. Orlando as a friend of Wilkie's, and Fred Albert, court stenographer, Wilkie has made a statement which repudiates a 'confession' he made to me earlier this week.
"He states that he found his son, James, dead of a gunshot wound when he returned to his home early on the morning of Dec. 20.
"Wilkie states that he concocted his story that he and his son wrestled over possession of the gun, which was Wilkie's service revolver, and that the gun was discharged accidentally.
Father Denied Suicide
"Wilkie told us he had determined to do everything within his power, say anything and be willing to take any kind of punishment, in order to obtain a Catholic funeral for his son.
"He still insists that his son did not commit suicide, that he had just bought some new clothes and had said or done nothing to indicate he might take his life.
"I must say here that the facts available to us do not coincide with a theory of accidental death.
"After Wilkie had made his 'confession' to us, we had him illustrate several times with county detectives how he said he tussled with his son. We knew then the son could not have been accidentally shot in such a struggle.
State Police Tests
"All tests by state police laboratories and our medical reports clearly evidenced Wilkie was not telling the truth.
"The bullet entered one temple and emerged from the other on a straight line instead of at an angle. The course the bullet took made it clear the shot was fired with deliberation by a gun held in the decedent's hands or in some other hands.
"Since a complaint has been made and a court has instructed me to present this matter to the grand jury, I must do so. Therefore the charge of manslaughter will remain pending the grand jury's deliberation."
Wilkie, according to Sheriff Hainsworth, spent a "restful day" Christmas in a cell in E block on the sixth floor of City Hall.
The sheriff said Wilkie was in "good spirits and talked frequently with other prisoners."
